Questions: Should you give a 5lb dog the same vaccination dosage as a 100lb dog ?
WHY are rabies vaccinations MANDATED by law every 3-years ?
WHY are “boosters” necessary if the first one was effective ?
Are there any negative side effects of vaccines for out pets ?
These are very good questions, but it seems the subject (and controversy) over pet vaccines is a subject that is discouraged from being discussed. In fact, there is one Doctor of Veterinarian Medicine (DMV) that has suffered dire consequences for doing just that. The veterinarian industry has come down very hard on this vet. He is leading the charge for changes to the landscape of pet vaccinations. Rabies vaccination in particular.
Rabies vaccinations for pets is the only vaccination mandated by every state. On one hand it is reasonable to support such because rabies is a very serious disease for both pets and humans. Once symptoms become apparent, certain death is to follow. Rabies is not curable.
However, the controversy is over dosage and frequency.
FREQUENCY: The rabies vaccine is marketed to humans as giving “immunity” from the disease. So then, if you have immunity why the need to vaccinate (or boost) every 3-years ? There is an old saying… don’t guess – TEST. Why are we giving our pets vaccinations they may not need?
There is an excellent podcast on this subject by Dr. John Robb here: https://vitalanimal.com/dr-robb-titers-immune-certificates-ep-4/ In this podcast he describes in detail the issues with blindly vaccinating our pets. This podcast is packed with information from start to finish (30-minutes) and I think it is well worth your time to listen. Did you know there is a test to see if your pet already has immunity from many diseases (including rabies) from previous vaccinations. If the test indicates current immunity, why re-vaccinate ? Could the reason be profits ? You may already suspect the answer to that. As they say… follow the money !
DOSAGE: Should the dose be dependent on the weight of the animal ? Should a 5-pound dog get the same dosage as a 100-pound dog ? Common sense would say no… but the maker of the vaccine recommends the same dose for both dogs (5lb v 100lb). I don’t know of any other medication that is not dependent on the weight of the patient… so why not for pets ? Here again, could the reason be profits ?
With dosages being the same no matter the weight of the pet, there is now evidence that smaller dogs suffer increased adverse reactions to same-size dossing recommendations. See the chart below. Pounds of dogs on the left, adverse reactions on the right. You can see that 11lb dogs on average suffer 45 adverse reactions, while 99lb dogs suffer only 17 adverse reactions on average. This data is courtesy of: https://www.protectthepets.com/uploads/1/0/8/0/108023613/dosages_are_linear_by_weight_2017_j_robb.pdf and has a lot of other important data also.
Seems pretty clear that dosage really does (or should) matter !
As you will hear in the podcast, many DVM’s recommend rabies vaccine at 12-weeks. Dr. Robb suggests waiting to at least 16 weeks, and suggests 6-months is better. He states that at 12-weeks there could still be residual parental immunity and therefore the vaccination will be less (or none at all) effective, hence the importance of testing for antibodies ((Titer test), With a Titer test immunity can be judged. As the doctor put it… immunity, you either have it or you don’t, sort of like a pregnancy test, you’re either pregnant or you’re not.
If this subject concerns you, check with your veterinarian to see if they can write a “waiver” (or “exemption”) to confirm that your pet has immunity for Rabies as confirmed by a Titer test. As you will hear in the podcast, the State of Delaware is the only state to accept a veterinarian rabies waiver/exemption in lieu of a rabies shot. Although you may find that a positive Titer test may be sufficient for lesser level requirement like an apartment complex, home owners association, etc.
Here is a link to an excellent site with in-depth information on this subject: https://www.protectthepets.com/
Keep in mind that a Titer test is certainly more expensive than just getting the shot… but is it worth the risk that an adverse reaction may harm your pet. And just because the pet may not have had any adverse reaction the last rabies shot, doesn’t guarantee any subsequent shot will not have an adverse reaction.
Have you had any pets that have had any adverse reactions to any vaccinations? Tell others your story and you may just save someone a lot of grief.